Welcome back to the Insecure Writer’s Support Group, which convenes the first Wednesday of every month to commiserate over worries, fears, doubts, and struggles.
This month’s question is:
Book reviews are for the readers. When you leave a book review, do you review for the Reader or the Author? Is it about what you liked and enjoyed about your reading experience, or do you critique the author?
When I review either a book or album, I not only review it for the actual audience, but for newbies to that author, band, or singer. When I was making the transition from casual lawnseat fan to hardcore, serious Who fan, I read all the album reviews at thewho.net (now only available through archive.org, sadly), and came to discover most of them weren’t written with new fans in mind. Thus, when I wrote my own reviews, I geared them towards people without years of fandom under their belts and all this detailed historical knowledge.
Someone on Amazon once left a nasty comment on one of my reviews, asking why I always mention if a book, album, or film is a good fit for a new fan or more for a serious, longtime fan. How in blazes are new fans supposed to figure out what to get first, what’s better-suited for when they’re more established in their fandom, and what’s best saved for last? It’s so arrogant to presume only other hardcore fans of 20+ years will be reading reviews for confirmation bias!
Personally attacking a writer because you didn’t like the story, and presuming to speak for his/her motivations and inspirations when you don’t even know him/her, is completely unprofessional and unacceptable.
I won my tenth official NaNo and lucky number thirteen overall with 57K, which is one of my lowest wordcounts but a big success considering the vast majority of my project was handwritten and how much I’ve been struggling since lockdown and the cancellation of all in-person write-ins for two years. When you’ve plummeted deep into a chasm, you can’t just climb out immediately and resume your normal life like nothing happened.
My project, Part 65ish of my magnum opus Cinnimin, is set from 12 September 2001–25 June 2002, but I only got up to the morning of 17 September, the eve of Rosh Hashanah. Those were some heavy High Holidays that year.
I loved using so many of my beautiful fountain pens and inks for each set of characters and each day of the story. The one constant was this lovely Retro 51 Autumn Leaves pen with an extra fine nib, which was refilled seven times during NaNo and always inked with Diamine’s Fire Embers. All of Raizel’s scenes are written with this ink-pen combo.
I’m also really proud of how well I wrote the Pashto quote at the beginning, after practising it a number of times to make sure I got the spacing and formation of the letters as perfect as possible. I have almost no experience with writing Arabic scripts, but I hope to keep improving.
As you may have heard, there’s a huge ongoing scandal with a mod of the Young Writers Program being accused of grooming minors and directing them to his creepy diaper fetish website, which began being scrubbed after authorities finally got involved. The Berkeley brass ignored complaints for years, as though this were so much less important than constantly issuing polarizing political statements that have ZERO to do with writing.
I’ll be discussing my feelings about whether to continue participating in NaNo or not in more detail in future posts. I truly hope there are serious changes in their management and they get back to their non-political roots.
This was also a very difficult month to get as much writing done as usual, since I’ve been so preoccupied by the terrifying skyrocketing in antisemitism worldwide, plus the fate of our precious hostages. I even used my phone on Shabbat to check Instagram and Twitter for constant updates. The Jewish community hasn’t been the same since 7 October, but we’re also more united than ever.
Praise God, all the children age 18 and under have been rescued except the two Bibas boys, 4-year-old Ariel and 10-month-old Kfir. Little Kfir has become everyone’s baby, and we all hope and pray he’s still alive.
Once all this is over, I’ll have more peace of mind and be able to devote more time to writing each day.
How did you do on NaNo this year, if you participated? Have current events ever demanded you focus less on your writing?