Why I can’t age up my Atlantic City characters, Part III (A Bildungsroman’s anchors matter)

The primary reason it seemed in theory to be very easy to “just” age up my original generation of characters by two years was because I have by far the biggest free space to radically restructure the 1940s books. I only got up to spring of 1944 in the Saga of the Sewards, my original WTCOAC (We the Children of Atlantic City) series is permanently shelved, the WTCOAC books jumped from September 1945 to April 1947 regardless, the main text of the first draft of Saga I of Cinnimin ends on V-J Day and segues into a long narrative summing up what happened between then and early September 1950, and the material I rewrote and expanded about Lazarus and Malchen in America in 1947 needs more editing. Perfect opportunity to do everything different and better, right?

I couldn’t have been more wrong. Only on paper did it sound like an awesome idea.

I always intended the 1940s to be their decade of upper elementary school, junior high, high school, and the peculiar institution of 13th grade, with the 1950s serving as their college years and entry into the adult world with marriage, children, and their own homes. If they finished high school in 1947, that would put their college graduation in 1951 and split the structuring of their coming of age in a very awkward way.

Also, I like the dynamic of their high school years being in the second half of the decade, after the war. It creates a very different state of mind and formative experience than if they began during the war.

Likewise, starting university in 1947 creates a very different collegiate experience than doing it in 1950. I had all these lofty plans for them to go to Swarthmore on scholarships from their school’s progressive track, Cinni and her friends to live in the other half of the massive Wilmington duplex Cinni and Sparky spend a weekend at during a polio scare in 1940, and at least Cinni and Sparky to go to grad school in New York, but that doesn’t really fit with the characters they’ve long been established as.

Instead, it makes more sense to keep developing Cinni’s newfound love of history and desire to switch to her school’s progressive track in junior high, so it feels much more compelling when all her exciting plans for her future are derailed by getting pregnant her freshwoman year of college, and then getting pregnant seven more times in a row each year, with only the fifth and sixth kids planned. By the time she has her final kids in 1960 and 1963, she’s locked into her role as a full-time mother of multitudes.

Sparky’s future plans likewise are derailed by getting pregnant in freshwoman year, and having three back-to-back kids.

I had the brilliant idea for Cinni and Kit to go abroad their junior year, on the urging of an advisor or professor who felt the change of scenery would do them a healing world of good after a tragedy in 1949 that personally impacts both of them. But if Cinni were to study in Italy and Kit in England, that would fundamentally alter who they’re supposed to be. There was nothing wrong with my original plot of Kit’s British ex Peter coming to America to say he hasn’t been able to stop thinking of her, Kit deciding to go back to England with him, and a terrible misunderstanding causing them to break up again.

This decade will continue to be radically rewritten and restructured, but it won’t suddenly change to them being two years ahead in school and starting college in 1947.

While many things in their fifth grade year were strongly modelled after my own seventh grade year, and their seventh grade year was largely drawn from my ninth grade year, that disconnect sharply levels off by the start of eighth grade in 1944. When they start high school, their mental and chronological ages are more or less synched.

Even though they certainly read as a few years older, I could never fully reimagine them as being that new age. Part of what makes them feel so unique and realistic is this straddling of two worlds, acting like they’re mature beyond their years while thinking with the necessarily immature brains of their true age. It’s like a female figure skater whose brain and body are thrown out of alignment by puberty, knowing how to do all the jumps but not yet familiar with the strange new proportions of her body affecting her technique.

Why I can’t age up my Atlantic City characters, Part II (Advanced maternal age)

Beyond the fact that I’m emotionally attached to the original generation of my Atlantic City characters being born from 1929–31, the reason I kept coming back to when agonising back and forth over whether or not to age them up by two years was the advanced maternal age of many of the women when they have their final children, or when they have children period after waiting longer than usual.

While I’m very happy to discover so many lovely ladies on Instagram who naturally had kids in their forties and fifties, and love how more and more research is coming to light showing we’ve long grossly overestimated the odds against women past forty conceiving and having healthy kids, the fact remains that two years are a lot of difference when we’re talking about pregnancy at that stage of life.

Writing these kids out of Cinnimin is completely out of the question, since the majority of them are integral to important storylines and are among the main characters of the current youngest leading generation.

Gayle and R.R. (Ralph Roger) delay parenthood for a long time and then struggle to conceive once they finally decide it’s time. On Valentine’s Day 1970, Gayle gives birth to Valentine, who marries Cinni’s grandson Ajax. In 1977, Gayle gives birth to Ernie, who’ll marry Cinni and Violet’s mutual granddaughter Crystal, and in 1981, Gayle has twins Dylan and Duvessa. Dylan will marry Violet’s daughter Juliet, and Duvessa will marry Cinni’s grandson Zeke.

The same day Valentine is born, Cinni’s unexpected dear friend Eleanor Black (one of the older sisters of Dave, Violet’s first boyfriend) gives birth to her only child, Aphrodite. Eleanor, who was born in 1925, impersonated a woman from an escort service and slept with a 23-year-old man when she was ovulating. Aphrodite has been a very important character since she was a teen in the Eighties, and her son Keith will marry Cinni and Violet’s mutual granddaughter Carolina.

Kit and Sparky both have babies in 1974, Raspberry Ann and Fritz, respectively, who marry one another. Of Kit’s four daughters, Raspberry Ann is by far the one most made in her spitfire, iconoclastic image, and also freely, matter-of-factly overshares details about her sex life regardless of her audience.

Kit and Sparky also have children in 1982, Charles and Adah, respectively. Kit and her second husband Peter really want to have a second biological child together (at the time assuming her first husband Rob had to be the father of her oldest six kids, despite their ongoing affair), and Sparky views Adah as a miraculous replacement for third-born Hannah, whom the family sat shiva for when she abandoned Judaism and married a man who goes on to drag her into fundamentalist Pentecostalism. Charles will marry Cinni’s granddaughter Dora, and Adah will marry her grandson Alyoshka (Aleksey).

Cinni’s sister Stacy (real name Eustacia) finally has live children in 1973 and 1981, Holden Grigoriy (named for their dad) and Krystyna (after their maternal grandma). Stacy was born in 1928, and never wanted kids. Her first pregnancy ended in miscarriage in 1963, and then she had two “lucky accidents” and two outright on-purpose late-term miscarriages before her husband Rodger finally averted another planned “accident.” Stacy is never very nurturing or maternal.

Henry and Adeline have been the laughingstock of town for years because they were such squeaky-clean goody-goodies growing up and then decided to be childfree so they could focus on their sex life. In 1979, Adeline gets pregnant, and since they’re devout Christians, abortion never crosses their minds. Miranda (Randi) is born in 1980, and will marry Cinni and Violet’s mutual grandson Perseus.

Violet has twins Portia and Juliet in September 1981, a month before her 51st birthday. Having had two sets of triplets and another set of twins, Violet is demonstrably hyperfecund.

Helouise, who only married in her mid-forties, finally becomes a mother to Matthew in 1982 and April in 1983. Matthew’s initial rejection of Portia first compels her into trying to win him by dressing like a hooker and finally launches her into deep depression culminating in slitting her wrists.

Quintina has a child, Claude, with her second husband Rex, after already having three kids (twins and a singleton) from her first marriage. Claude is born in 1982. I really only created him so he could marry April and they could give lifelong best friends Quintina and Helouise mutual grandkids.

Samantha has Lyle in 1982, born during her second marriage. She lost custody of her daughter Adolfa (called Olfie for obvious reasons) after her first husband divorced her, and Adolfa, born in 1961, ran away from Attu Island, Alaska and made her way to New Jersey to reunite with her in 1976. Lyle is by far the most expendable of all these late-life kids, since he hasn’t doesn’t really done anything as of 1998, other than giving Adolfa the surreal experience of having a baby halfbrother who’s only four months older than her own first child Ivy.

Filipa Polanska finally realises her lifelong dream of marrying her unrequited love Samuel Roblensky in 1981 after he exits his never-happy first marriage, and very shortly gets pregnant with twins, Beryl (a boy) and Etke, at the extraordinarily high age of 55. Beryl will marry Sparky’s granddaughter Tzeitel, and Etke will marry Sparky’s grandson Oskar (who’s also Etke’s first-cousin once-removed).

Sunday Snippets—A scandalous Thanksgiving gift

Though the long-running Weekend Writing Warriors seems to be officially over for all intents and purposes, I’ve decided to keep its spirit alive by sharing my own snippets on Sundays. There are no more rules about a certain number of lines, so we get to decide how much to include now!

For this year’s Thanksgiving snippets, I’m sharing a scene from the largely-unedited currently-numbered ninth book in my Saga of the Sewards series, which has the corny, cringey working title Who Said Junior High Was Supposed to Be Easy? It’s Thanksgiving 1943, and a very strange holiday offering was delivered to the Seward mansion, purportedly from cousins Max and Elaine’s friend Helouise.

The item inside the package isn’t exactly the kind of thing anyone normal wants to see at Thanksgiving dinner!

Gene reached into Max’s pocket and pulled out the mystery object. Max grabbed it from his hand and stuffed it back into his pocket.

“What am I supposed to do with this, frame it?” Max stamped on Gene’s toes. “I threw it in the garbage for a reason, since I’m serious about turning over a new leaf and doing things differently. Even if I wanted to revert to my old ways, I couldn’t use something that was at the bottom of a trash can. This would be a better present for Allie, since she was the only one who was upset about me trashing it.” He grinned. “I should send it to her in a frame if this supposed memento means so much to her, though no one normal wants to publicly display that.”

“What in the world are you talking about?” Mr. Seward asked. “Something tells me this isn’t the innocent Thanksgiving gift I naïvely assumed it was.”

Max held up the dried, shriveled, brittle, cracking, surrealistic souvenir for a split second before stuffing it back into his pocket. “My old rubber. I can’t believe I’m admitting this, but you were right and I was wrong, Dad. It really was unhealthy and disgusting to keep reusing it.”

Mr. Seward had turned purple, and his face was contorted into a grimace. “I’m sorry I asked.”

“I bet Maxwell set the entire thing up just to ruin Thanksgiving,” Marianne snarled from the servants’ table. “He arranged for an equally crude friend to drop this package off at the house, put this young lady’s return address on it to ward off any suspicions, and wrote this shocking letter to go with it. My money is on Dave Black as the guilty party, knowing what he’s like.”

“Why would I do something so disgusting?” Max looked at the letter again. “Now that you mention it, this does look like Dave’s messy handwriting, not Hellie’s. It’s just the kind of thing he’d do. Dave is the grossest person I’ve ever known.”

Why I can’t age up my Atlantic City characters, Part I (Everything hits too differently)

When you’ve been with characters long enough, you intrinsically come to know them inside and out. Having created the original generation of my Atlantic City characters on 25 November 1991 and into that December, too much time has passed to truly think of them as anything but the age I always wrote them as.

And one of many reasons I always sensed deep down that I could never go through with it and retcon them as two years older was because too many things were so tightly, intricately intertwined and constructed in a certain way. Everything would unravel if I suddenly altered it.

So many things would just hit different if their ages were changed. E.g., Violet’s relationship with her older sister Mandy is the way it is because they’re four years apart, not only two, just as Max has the same kind of relationship with his older sister Tiffany because of their own four-year age difference. (And yes, I doubtless wouldn’t have named them Amanda and Tiffany had I created them as an adult, but it’s not like those names are totally implausible for girls born in 1926.)

Lazarus and Sparky’s emotional reunion in 1947 wouldn’t feel the same if they were eighteen instead of sixteen. It might only be two years of difference, but those two years are huge when you’re a teen! Plus, why would Lazarus be taken in by a Scottish Jewish foster family from early 1946 to January 1947 if he were already a legal adult? That’s a very formative detail of his early postwar experience!

Samuel wouldn’t have incentive to take on a protective big brother role to Lazarus if they were only a year apart instead of three. Of course they’d still become as close as real brothers due to what they go through together, but it wouldn’t be the same if they’re equal peers. After Lazarus and Malchen are deported to the Warsaw Ghetto and find a home with the orphaned Robleński siblings and their aunts, Samuel often derides Lazarus as a naïve little boy and greenhorn who has no concept of the grave danger they’re in, even up to Lazarus rejoicing over their names appearing on a deportation list and then sneaking back into Treblinka to get the older Robleńskis to escape to his new hiding place. (In the early days of the camp, there were quite a few escapes enabled by the absolute chaos under “Dr.” Irmfried Eberl’s management.)

Likewise, would I then have had to make Lazarus’s little sister Malchen (Amalia) two years older as well, or kept her 1932 birth year and made her four years younger? If the former, her own sisterly bond with Jadwiga Robleńska (who later becomes her sister-in-law) would be radically altered. Lazarus entrusts Jadwiga with taking care of Malchen when their hiding place is discovered in September 1943 and they’re separated. Malchen is twelve and Jadwiga is sixteen at liberation, which creates a much different bond than if they were fourteen and sixteen.

Violet becomes pregnant in the spring of 1943, by Gayle’s boyfriend R.R. (Ralph Roger), and takes an inordinate amount of pills to induce an abortion. Shortly afterwards, her mother Madeline announces her own long-awaited third pregnancy, and Violet frequently mistreats and neglects Scarlett. Were Violet two years older, she’d still have a lot of complicated feelings to work through, particularly with the timing of her baby sister’s birth around the time she would’ve had her own baby, but she’d have a bit more baseline maturity preventing her from acting out to that degree.

Cinni loses her father the day after her tenth birthday. That would of course still be a life-altering tragedy were she just turned twelve, particularly given their super-close relationship, but again, those two years of difference are huge at such a young age.

Cinni’s mother’s birth year is set as 1900, her dad’s birth year is 1893, and her maternal aunt Lucinda’s birth year is 1910. Aging them up would then in turn necessitate aging up their own parents, who are important secondary characters, as well as Cinni’s great-grandma Bogda and great-great-grandma Tatjana, who celebrates her 100th birthday in 1940 in a double ceremony with Max’s great-great-grandpa (also named Max).

It’s established that Lucinda was unhappily married to the much-older Jasper when she was eighteen, and that Cinni’s cousin Elmira, one year her senior, was conceived on their wedding night. That kind of sets Elmira’s birth year as 1929!

Sparky’s older brothers Gary and Barry (né Friedrich and Otto) are so overprotective towards her because they’re six and four years older. Were they only four and two years older, their relationship would be a lot different.

A big reason Cinni has such a hard time adjusting to motherhood and a semblance of a more maternal role is because she gets pregnant with Demian at only twenty, and has him on her twenty-first birthday. Then the kids arrive like clockwork every year until 1958, and her final two are born in 1960 and 1963. Were she two years older, she would’ve had a bit more time to experience independent adult life. Instead she treats her kids like miniature adults and comrades-in-arms, with no conception of why that isn’t healthy or normal.

Everything was linked together too deliberately, with the foundation of their original birth years too indelibly baked into dozens of books, to ever realistically be frogged so many decades later and replaced with alien new ages. Had their stories stopped in 1970, the ending year of my Saga of the Sewards series, it probably could’ve worked with a lot of editing, but Fate decreed sticking to my original vision.

The most unrealistic and ridiculous things in the books of Beatrice Sparks

Dr. Fraud and her books are truly the gifts that keep on giving. No matter how many posts I’ve written about them over the years, the well hasn’t run anywhere close to dry yet. While I’ve discussed obvious signs these books weren’t written by real teens and aren’t real journals, how we know she wasn’t a real psychologist (beyond being thoroughly exposed as a fraud), and why I hate Dr. Fraud in general, I haven’t specifically delved into the most unrealistic and ridiculous things in general across all of her books.

1. The fact that such a terrible writer was handed a publishing contract to begin with, and kept getting published! The powers that be cared more about delivering fear-mongering lessons to “the kids” instead of quality writing and fact-checking. I’m gobsmacked to learn publishing houses still don’t routinely employ fact-checkers, though at least a fraud of this scale could never be pulled off longterm in the Internet age.

2. The fact that anyone believed she was a real psychologist. I truly hope no one believed the toxic, dangerous, damaging, irresponsible nonsense she preached, like about repressing trauma asap, magically thinking oneself out of a suicidal crisis, and never having any negative thoughts about anyone.

3. Annie, a teen girl of the Nineties, goes to a freaking unwed mothers’ home. Nice job defaulting back to the Fifties, Dr. Fraud!

4. Annie has what suspiciously sounds like a twilight sleep birth. Again, completely anachronistic by the Nineties!

5. And “Li’l Annie” goes home from hospital after only about two weeks, despite being two months premature. This fraud well and truly couldn’t think outside of her own formative era!

6. Nancy goes from contracting HIV to dying of full-blown late-stage AIDS in just under two years. That didn’t happen even at the height of the epidemic before HAART and even AZT! It enrages me that she got away with pretending the CDC approval letter got lost in the mail.

7. None of these characters are bullied for being so joined at the hip with their freaking mothers. That’s the kind of thing that gets your ass kicked at school when word gets out. No one normal likes a goody-goody who’s constantly declaring her WUB for her pwecious, pwecious, pwecious Mommykins, whom she’s sooooooooo glad is HER dear, sweet, pwecious Mamakins, and whom she can’t get enough of cuddling with like a baby. Even more ridiculous how Mark in VOICES can’t function without Mamakins to snuggle him, bake him cookies, read him stories, clean for him, and nag at him. “That just showed what a big baby butt I was!” Damn right, loser!

8. Kim jumps from her first idle thoughts about losing weight to full-blown disordered relationship with food in less than one month, and is cured almost instantly.

9. Nancy, a fellow Gen Xer raised in the era of Stranger Danger, Very Special Episodes, and Afterschool Specials, thinks nothing of Collin rubbing her back and taking her into an empty hall, getting a ride home with him, meeting him in isolated places, inviting him home when she’s alone, and locking all the doors and windows.

10. Kim: Empty Inside was published in April 2002, despite the calendar dates going until May. No real diary would keep going past its own publication date!

11. Kim gets to move right into a sorority house because Mommykins and tHe tWiNs were members. That ain’t how legacies work. There’s also zero mention of rushing or pledging. I never belonged to a sorority, and even I know more about how they work than Dr. Fraud!

12. Katie vanishes from her rich community and school with no attempts to look for her, and the foster care system and her new school take her at her word when she claims to be two years younger. What is this, the Victorian era?

13. Alice journals on paper bags and napkins, keeps this ramshackle collection in chronological order, and totes it around as she moves from place to place while homeless.

14. Alice is able to write with bulky bandages on her hands.

15. And she’s able to bring her journal and writing instruments into a psych ward!

16. Mary is immediately recruited into a cult rather than being gradually groomed over months or even years, and is hit with a three-day lecture as soon as she arrives at the compound. Cults are so successful precisely because they inculcate people so subtly and slowly their members don’t realise what’s going on. They’d never retain anyone if they hit people with hardcore cult tactics from the jump. Also, it’s biologically impossible to hold your urine and stay in the same sitting position, with your head and arms on a cross-shaped beam, for three days.

17. Collin spends all of ten days grooming Nancy before drugging her drink and violently raping her. Real groomers take 6–9 months before making that first move, and don’t launch into full-on sex immediately. That’s why it’s called grooming, because it happens in stages.

18. Faye only takes two months grooming Millie before making her own first move, which is of course immediate full-on sex. Dr. Fraud could never be arsed to actually develop characters and storylines over realistic periods!

19. Cops conduct an investigation into a perp criminally transmitting HIV by contacting every Abraham Lincoln Junior High School in the U.S. and asking them to send yearbooks so Nancy can look for Collin’s picture. That ain’t how police investigations work!

20. Nancy is still in junior high at age sixteen. Outside of Utah, the 7–9 junior high model had long since been discontinued by the Nineties. Dr. Fraud’s description of junior high ages also feels more like 8–10.

21. Nancy thinks nothing of using Mommy’s toothbrush on the regular, since she’s too lazy and nasty to take Mommy’s brush off the electric device and pop hers on. That’s beyond nasty and disgusting, and what family only has one electric toothbrush device for everyone?22. The creepy fetish-like adulation for body fluids! Jennie swoons over Mommy drooling on her while they’re bawling and cuddling in bed, Kim practically gets off on wiping drool off of red flag Lawrence’s mouth while he’s snoring (which also gets her off) with his head on her lap in the car, Sammy loves when his dog drools on him in bed.