In memory of all those whose lives were lost 78 years ago today on Kristallnacht, and at Babi Yar.

I wanted to do a post marking the 75th anniversary of the massacre by Babi Yar, the largest single massacre of the Shoah up till that date (29–30 September 1941). This was also the largest Einsatzgruppen massacre in the former Soviet Union. For the most part, the Jewish communities in the occupied USSR were murdered by mobile killing squads, not in ghettoes and camps.

Historically, there was a lot of anti-Semitism in this part of Europe, so there were many local collaborators, both active and silent. While there were also heroes, the majority didn’t do anything to help or protest. Pointing out widespread anti-Semitism, with deep historic roots, in certain countries isn’t meant to be a bash against them and their people. All countries have black marks in their pasts. Denying or downplaying it is intellectually dishonest.


This order, posted in Ukrainian, Russian, and German around 26 September 1941, read:

All Yids of the city of Kyiv and its vicinity must appear on Monday, 29 September 1941, by 8 o’clock in the morning at the corner of Melnika and Dokterivskiy Streets (near the cemetery).

Bring documents, money, and valuables, and also warm clothing, linen, etc.

Any Yids who do not follow this order and are found elsewhere will be shot.

Any civilians who enter the dwellings left by Yids and appropriate the things in them will be shot.

Copyright Markv at nl.wikipedia; Licensed under the GFDL by the author

The decision to murder all of Kyivan Jewry was made by Major-General Kurt Eberhard, the military governor; SS Obergruppenführer Friedrich Jeckeln, police commander for Army Group South; and Otto Rasch, Einsatzgruppe C Commander.

The murder itself was orchestrated by an SS Sonderkommando unit (not to be confused with the Jewish Sonderkommando squad, who carried out a brave revolt on 7 October 1944 and risked their lives to take and smuggle out four clandestine pictures in August 1944). SS and SD police, along with local police, assisted them.

Over 30,000 people dutifully reported, far exceeding the five or six thousand initially expected. They truly believed they’d be resettled. Instead, they were ordered, bit by bit, to leave their valuables and money, give up their luggage, and remove their shoes and each layer of clothes.

Given the size of the crowd, not many people suspected their cruel fate until the last moment, when they heard the machine guns. The ravine they were led to is called Babyn Yar in its native Ukrainian, and Babiy Yar in Russian. The standard English transliteration is Babi Yar, which I’m using for the sake of academic consistency.

In all, 33,771 people were murdered over those two days. Only a small minority were able to escape. At least 29 survivors are known. The only survivor to testify by a 1946 war crimes trial in Kyiv was Dina Mironivna Pronicheva, an actor by the Kyiv Puppet Theatre.

Sadly, only 10% (3,000) of the victims have been identified to date.

Memorial by Nachalat Yitzchak Cemetery, Givatayim, Israel; Copyright דוד שי (Dudi [David] Shay)

After the September 1941 massacre, the Nazis and their collaborators murdered over 100,000 other Kyivans by Babi Yar, right up until the Nazis were forced to retreat. They murdered political dissidents, Roma, POWs, and many other civilians. Patients of the Ivan Pavlov Psychiatric Hospital had their ashes dumped into the ravine after being gassed.

A concentration-camp, Syretskyy, was established a few hundred meters from the ravine in 1942, as a subcamp of Sachsenhausen. While the inmates were being forced to cover up traces of the mass grave in August and September 1943, they got hold of tools like screwdrivers, hammers, keys, and pieces of metal.

On the second anniversary of the first massacre, 29 September 1943, the prisoners revolted as the camp was dismantled. They overpowered the guards, and fifteen prisoners escaped. Sadly, the other 311 inmates were murdered once the Nazis regained control.

Ukrainian postage stamp issued for the 70th anniversary in 2011

Some of the souls lost are pictured below. Unless otherwise noted, they were all murdered by the first, largest massacre.


Velvel Valentin Pinkert in 1939


Anna Glinberg in 1935


Grigoriy Shehtman, born 1934


4-year-old Malvina Babat and 3-year-old Polina Babat


Mariya (Manya) Iosifivna Halef in 1936. She was seven when she was murdered.


Manya’s parents, Iosif Halef and Klara Halef-Miropolskaya


Olena Ivanivna Teliha, née Shovgeneva (21 July 1906–21 February 1942), a prominent poet and anti-Nazi activist


Mykhailo Pavlovych Teliha, her husband, 8/21 November 1900–21 February 1942. He played the bandura (a Ukrainian instrument like a zither crossed with a lute) professionally. Rather than take his freedom, he chose to stay with his wife.


Ivan Andriyovych Rohach (29 May 1913–21 February 1942), a prominent poet, writer, political activist, and journalist. He was murdered with his sister Hanna and the entire staff of his newspaper.

Yevgeniy Aleksandrovich Yevtushenko’s 1961 poem “Babi Yar” famously begins: “No monument stands over Babi Yar.” It wasn’t until 1976 that a monument was finally erected, only mentioning POWs and Soviet citizens. In 1991, a Jewish memorial finally appeared. Today, many other memorials dot the area.

7 thoughts on ““One long soundless scream”

  1. It’s bewildering to me that anyone could be so incredibly cold toward another group of people, but it happens even these days–maybe not to that extreme. It makes my heart ache for people to be more understanding and kind with one another, to put aside differences and try to see eye to eye.


  2. Thank you for your post. I didn’t lose relatives in Babi Yar. My family lived in Moldavia before the war. Everyone who didn’t evacuate to the east (luckily both sets of my grandparents did) was dead by the end of the war. We never knew when or how they died; no traces remained.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I never learned about this massacre, which shows you the lack of education in the school systems. This is tragic. Any kind of massacre just breaks my heart. Out of all of those people…29 survivors. It is just awful. Thank you for opening my eyes to this tragedy. The end was a heart-wrenching but beautiful tribute. I’m amazed that you were able to include pictures. Seeing the children is especially heartbreaking.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I was a little girl when my father first let me watch the TV mini-series, The Holocaust. I suppose that seems harsh information for a child, but my father fully believed that to ignore history is to repeat it. I remember asking him if the Germans were monsters and he said no- they were men and women like everyone else. They were placed in a set of circumstances that spawned the worst in humanity…and that we are all capable of that kind of behavior- especially when we think it could never be us.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks Elizabeth’s Dad.

      This was the message I received in a book series which featured the ordinary Germans and Austrians and their relationship to Nazism/National Socialism during the Second World War and just before it.

      I appreciate your father’s approach to history so very much.


  5. Carrie-Anne – when you said – at the end:

    “Yevgeniy Aleksandrovich Yevtushenko’s 1961 poem “Babi Yar” famously begins: “No monument stands over Babi Yar.” It wasn’t until 1976 that a monument was finally erected, only mentioning POWs and Soviet citizens. In 1991, a Jewish memorial finally appeared. Today, many other memorials dot the area.”

    That is where I first learnt about what Babi Yar was when I would read his poetry book in early 1996.

    I’d wondered if the memorials were for every ethnic and religious group that had been affected by the massacre.

    Thanks for the academic consistency – not having been a Russophile or Ukranophile back then [even though one of my grandfathers was – he did teach me some socialist and communist history during and after WWII – and encouraged me in my reading of those nations] I would not have picked up the other names.

    When you think about the killing squads … am reading a book called HOLLYWOOD’S WAR WITH POLAND 1933-45 which fills in quite a lot of knowledge and information that would not have been in my head before about 2011 [because of Danusha Goska’s book BIEGANSKI].

    And the mental picture of the ravine…

    Liked by 1 person

Share your thoughts respectfully

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s