I honestly never thought I’d have the stomach to sit through The Birth of a Nation a second time, yet on 28 May 2015, that’s exactly what I did. It showed up in the list of silent films on my parents’ Netflix on Apple TV when I was house-sitting for a week recently, and I just felt myself pulled towards revisiting it. And I’m really, really, really glad I did.

The first time I saw the film was 21 May 2006, the night TCM premiered the long-lost Beyond the Rocks, along with showing more silent films than they usually do on Sunday nights. Prior to starting the Valentino films, they aired BOAN. I was so nervous and scared, my stomach was in knots. I was also very close to my 500th silent, and relieved BOAN only ended up as #495.

At this time, I was active on a message board which no longer exists, run by a rather rigid, reactionary admin with an extremely Victorian view of the world. I’m not talking about a woman who was merely very conservative, but a complete reactionary who wouldn’t respect any other POVs, said many insulting, offensive things, banned folks for no reason, defended McCarthyism, and drove away many venerable silent film scholars. She frequently interrupted great discussions of films to deliver an off-topic polemic. (See some evidence.)

Anyway, this admin and some of the other folks there were really pro-D.W. Griffith, and brushed off any objections to how racist BOAN is. Look, there’s being too PC, and there’s being genuinely shocked and offended by truly offensive, racist material. If you can watch that entire film and just calmly think, “Oh, that’s just how things were then,” without once feeling at all uncomfortable, there’s something wrong. I might cringe at stereotypical depictions of Native Americans or the serious identification of a woman as Mrs. Husband’s Full Name in an old film, but that won’t bug me if it’s just a small portion of the overall film. I was nervous the first time I watched The Jazz Singer, but I relaxed once I realized Al Jolson is only in blackface for a little bit, and that it’s very matter-of-fact, not at all offensive in a historical context. BOAN isn’t like that at all.

I had a huge chip on my shoulder when I first watched D.W. Griffith’s films, and this biased attitude also extended to Lillian Gish, whom I now love. I didn’t really start to have any sort of positive opinion towards Griffith till I saw his early Biograph shorts, which I highly recommend. My appreciation of Lillian Gish didn’t begin till I started watching her later MGM films. And honestly, there are more reasons besides BOAN why I disliked Griffith so much. He really beats viewers over the head with his Victorian moralizing, preachiness, oversentimentality, and extreme black and white view of the world, along with his “dear little one” characters.

Many times during my first viewing, I gasped and groaned, so in shock and horror of what I was watching. Going in, I was actually terrified I was going to throw up. But oddly enough, my recent second viewing was a bit more emotionally easy. It’s still a very challenging film to watch in the modern era, but this time around, I was more able to appreciate and admire it as a brilliant piece of storytelling, a gripping epic, a masterful milestone in cinematic history. I felt that the first time too, but I was just too overwhelmed by all the racism to focus on the bigger picture.

The worst thing about this film is how damn good it is. This is a film everyone needs to see at least once, particularly if you love silent cinema in particular or cinematic history in general.

6 thoughts on “BOAN at 100, Part I (My history with the film)

  1. BOAN is truly a great film and historically significant. I’ve watched the entire film at least 3 times all the way through. I have a DVD copy. I think it is important to put the film in the perspective of its times and the mentality that brought about its creation.

    I think that perhaps Intolerance is a still greater film with even more compelling storytelling. That’s a film that I’d like to see again since I’ve only seen it once in its entirety.

    Good to see you discussing these films. It’s sad that there is so little interest in them among recent generations.

    Arlee Bird
    A to Z Challenge Co-host
    Road trippin’ with A to Z
    Tossing It Out


  2. I have to say that I will probably never watch this film. Making this is barbecue I am an African American, but it seems too be too much. Lots of movies of course were racist back then. And Carrie-Anne, you are right in that there is a difference between a movie that is racist because “it’s a product of its time” and because the director very deliberately wanted to send a racist message. I mean I can watch lots of classic cartoons and deal with the racism in them, but that’s because a lot of the time it is not as blatant, and the moments are fleeting for the most part, and a lot of the time, at least they did not mean any harm, though it must be emphasized that positive intent does not matter much in the grand scheme of things if the end result is negative Of course, the movie was greatly condemned to the point of Griffith making the film Intolerance to apologize for it.

    I can understand the historical significance of the film. I recognize that it was revolutionary in storytelling and other filmmaking techniques. I also understand the fact that movies today would not be what they are without Birth of a Nation. I just wish that it had been a different movie.


  3. I confess I haven’t seen the film, but I do understand its importance. Now that I’m a little older and wiser, I would better see it for what it is rather than something I purposely avoided because I believed it to be racist. A very thought provoking post.


  4. I’ve never seen a silent film in its entirety. I think I’ll watch this because this post has piqued my interest. I’ve only stopped watching a few things because of a strong emotional reaction.


Share your thoughts respectfully

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s